Reviewed by Dr. Brittany Ryan-Berzins, PhD — licensed clinical psychologist with 20+ years of experience treating anxiety, depression, and trauma.
College athletes are expected to perform like competitors, manage school like students, and handle pressure like adults who already have it all figured out.
From the outside, you look focused and capable. You show up to practice. You go to class. You travel with the team. You keep pushing because that is what athletes are trained to do. Inside, though, the pressure starts to feel harder to control.
Often, it shows up before the competition even begins. Your body feels tense. Your thoughts become harder to quiet. A mistake from practice keeps replaying, and the fear of disappointing someone starts to take up more space than the game itself.
For college athletes, performance anxiety reaches beyond performance. Practice feels heavier. Schoolwork becomes harder to focus on. Over time, the sport that once gave you joy can start to feel pressured, draining, and hard to keep showing up for.
In this Article
Why college athletes feel so much pressure
College sports can bring opportunity, structure, and purpose. They also bring a level of pressure many athletes have never had to manage before.
The expectations often come from several directions:
- Coaches are watching every practice
- Teammates competing for the same position
- Parents who have invested significant time and money
- Scholarships, rankings, and playing time
- Academic demands that continue throughout the season
- Injury recovery and fear of losing progress
Many athletes respond by doing what has always helped them improve: they work harder. They stay later at practice or review mistakes long after everyone else has moved on. Eventually, that effort starts to feel less like discipline and more like pressure.
Even talented, committed athletes can begin to lose confidence when every performance feels like a test of who they are, not just how they played.
What sports performance anxiety can look like
Performance anxiety does not look the same for every athlete. For some, it starts before the competition. For others, it shows up during practice, after a mistake, or when returning from injury.
An athlete struggling with performance anxiety often notices:
- Racing thoughts before games or meets
- Physical tension before competition
- Trouble sleeping the night before an event
- Fear of making mistakes in front of others
- Difficulty staying focused under pressure
- Replaying performance afterward
- Avoiding certain drills or situations
- Feeling less confident despite being physically prepared
Some athletes feel fine until the moment performance matters. Others feel anxious for days leading up to an event. Either way, the experience is frustrating because the athlete knows what they are capable of, but pressure gets in the way of trusting their training.
Why anxiety can keep getting stronger
Performance anxiety often grows when competition starts to feel threatening.
A mistake feels dangerous. A coach’s feedback feels personal. A bad game becomes proof that you are falling behind. The more pressure you feel to control the outcome, the harder it becomes to stay present.
Many athletes try to solve the problem by thinking more. They review every mistake, prepare for every possible scenario, and push themselves to be tougher. Sometimes that effort helps. Other times, it keeps the anxiety cycle going.
Sports psychology can help athletes change their relationship with pressure. Competitive stress will always be part of athletics. The goal is to help athletes respond with more focus, flexibility, and control when that pressure rises.
What sports psychology can do for performance anxiety
Sports psychology focuses on the mental side of performance. For a college athlete, that often means learning what happens under pressure and how to respond with more focus.
Therapy can teach practical cognitive and behavioral strategies that athletes can use in real situations. This work can help athletes prepare for competition, recover from mistakes, stay focused during play, and build confidence over time.
Therapy can include skills such as:
- Relaxation training to reduce physical tension before competition
- Goal setting that keeps attention on controllable actions
- Motivation strategies for difficult stretches of the season
- Visualization and imagery to mentally rehearse performance
- Positive self-talk that supports confidence
- Mindfulness skills for staying present during competition
- Pre-performance routines that reduce overthinking
These skills can help athletes reduce stress and perform with more confidence. They can also make the mental side of performance feel more manageable.
For example, an athlete who freezes after a mistake can work on quickly resetting their attention. A runner who tenses before a race can practice relaxation and imagery before stepping to the line. A basketball player who gets stuck in self-criticism can work on replacing harsh internal language with specific performance cues.
Over time, athletes can develop a more intentional response to pressure rather than feeling controlled by it.
Working with the whole athlete
College athletes are more than their statistics or rankings. Sleep, academics, relationships, injuries, team dynamics, and personal stress can all affect how you feel and how you perform.
Sports psychology can support both performance and overall well-being. The goal is not only to help you compete with greater focus, but also to help you understand what is happening mentally and emotionally as the pressure builds.
Dr. Berzins has worked with collegiate, high school, Olympic, and professional athletes, as well as former professionals transitioning to life beyond sports. His background gives him a strong understanding of how performance can become tied to identity, opportunity, and future goals.
Treatment is tailored to the athlete. You may need support with game-day anxiety, injury recovery, a difficult season, or a loss of confidence. You may also be trying to perform at a high level while managing stress outside your sport.
No two athletes respond to pressure in exactly the same way. Therapy gives you a place to understand your own patterns and build strategies that fit your sport, your season, and your personal goals.
Support while you are away at school
One challenge for college athletes is continuity of care. You may begin therapy at home in New Jersey and then worry about losing that support when you leave for school.
If you are an athlete traveling out of state for college, you do not necessarily need to start over with a new therapist whenever your location changes. The Psychology Interjurisdictional Compact, known as PSYPACT, allows approved psychologists to provide telehealth services to eligible clients in participating states and jurisdictions. This can make it easier to continue therapy while you are away at school, during the season, between semesters, or when you return home for breaks. Instead of pausing support when pressure is highest, this program enables you to continue building skills and applying them in real time.
For students who return home during breaks, in-person therapy is also available in Pompton Plains, NJ.
Getting back to competing with confidence
Performance anxiety can make you feel disconnected from the version of yourself that used to compete with freedom and trust. Therapy can help you rebuild that connection.
The work often begins by looking at what happens before, during, and after high-pressure moments. From there, you can develop tools to manage physical anxiety, shift unhelpful thought patterns, recover from mistakes, and prepare for competition with greater clarity.
At Birch Tree Psychology in Pompton Plains, NJ, Dr. Peter Berzins works with athletes seeking practical support to manage pressure and perform with greater focus and confidence. Dr. Berzins is also a PSYPACT-participating psychologist, which allows him to provide telehealth therapy to eligible clients in participating states and jurisdictions. If performance anxiety is getting in the way of your game, reaching out is a practical next step toward getting support that fits your needs.
For college athletes in New Jersey and more than 40 eligible PSYPACT-participating states, therapy can help you stay supported across school, home, training, and competition.
FAQ
What is performance anxiety in college athletes?
Performance anxiety is anxiety that interferes with an athlete’s ability to compete, practice, or perform with confidence. It often affects focus, sleep, physical tension, decision-making, and recovery after mistakes.
Is performance anxiety only a problem during games?
No. Performance anxiety can show up before competition, during practice, after mistakes, while returning from injury, or during conversations with coaches. Some athletes feel anxious for days before an event.
How can sports psychology help college athletes?
Sports psychology can help athletes build practical skills for focus, confidence, emotional regulation, preparation, self-talk, visualization, relaxation, goal setting, and pressure management.
What is PSYPACT, and why does it matter for college athletes?
PSYPACT is an interstate agreement that allows approved psychologists to provide telehealth services across participating states. For college athletes who leave New Jersey for school, this can make it easier to continue therapy without having to start over with a new provider.
Can Birch Tree Psychology work with college athletes outside New Jersey?
Birch Tree Psychology provides therapy in New Jersey and offers telehealth for eligible clients in PSYPACT-participating states. This option can help college students continue to receive support while away at school.
Does an athlete need to be struggling badly to benefit from therapy?
No. Some athletes seek therapy because anxiety is interfering with performance. Others want support with focus, confidence, consistency, or recovery from setbacks. Therapy can be helpful before anxiety becomes overwhelming.
Reviewed by Dr. Brittany Ryan-Berzins, PhD.
Her clinical work focuses on anxiety, depression, trauma, life transitions, and women’s mental health using evidence-based, mindfulness-informed care.
References
Hatzigeorgiadis, A., Zourbanos, N., Galanis, E., & Theodorakis, Y. (2011). Self-talk and sports performance: A meta-analysis. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 6(4), 348–356. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691611413136
Reardon, C. L., Hainline, B., Aron, C. M., Baron, D., Baum, A. L., Bindra, A., Budgett, R., Campriani, N., Castaldelli-Maia, J. M., Currie, A., Derevensky, J. L., Glick, I. D., Gorczynski, P., Gouttebarge, V., Grandner, M. A., Han, D. H., McDuff, D., Mountjoy, M., Polat, A., … Engebretsen, L. (2019). Mental health in elite athletes: International Olympic Committee consensus statement. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 53(11), 667–699. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2019-100715
Simonsmeier, B. A., Andronie, M., Buecker, S., & Frank, C. (2021). The effects of imagery interventions in sports: A meta-analysis. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 14(1), 186–207. https://doi.org/10.1080/1750984X.2020.1780627
Weinberg, R. S., & Gould, D. (2019). Foundations of sport and exercise psychology (7th ed.). Human Kinetics.